Hello dear
Welcome to Old Tymers Cafe
Nestled in the heart of Red River, New Mexico, Old Tymers Cafe is a charming eatery that captures the essence of classic American dining. Known for its oversized pancakes—truly a challenge for the bravest of appetites—this cozy café offers a delectable array of dishes, from hearty salads and soups to savory American plates like chicken fried steak. Guests rave about the friendly service and inviting atmosphere, ensuring a memorable experience. Whether it's the well-seasoned green chili cheeseburger or the delightful house salads, Old Tymers Cafe delights diners with its comforting fare, making it a must-visit spot for locals and tourists alike.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Chips & Salsa
Cottage Cheese
Beef & Bean Burrito
Chicken Quesadilla
About
Old Tymers Cafe
Welcome to Old Tymers Cafe, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Red River, New Mexico. Located at 210 E Main St, this cozy eatery not only serves hearty meals but also embodies the charm of a small resort town renowned for its breathtaking ski slopes and vibrant summer activities. Whether you're stopping by after a long hike or looking for a warm meal after a day on the slopes, Old Tymers Cafe promises a welcoming atmosphere and delicious food.
The menu is a true testament to comfort food, featuring a variety of dishes that cater to every palate. One of the standout items is their famous pancakes, which have become a must-try. Customers rave about their size and taste; it's an amusing challenge to complete all three served at once! For those with hearty appetites, the challenge comes with a fun twist—you get a shirt if you can finish them!
If pancakes aren't your thing, the cafe also offers a selection of their signature green chili cheeseburgers that hit the right notes of flavor and spice. The beef is perfectly cooked, and the burger pairs beautifully with a side of golden, crispy tater tots or their homemade soups like Carolyn's Soup and Green Chili Stew. The salads are equally enticing, adding a refreshing touch to your meal.
Patrons often highlight the friendly service that accompanies the delicious food. With attentive staff members ensuring your drinks are always full, it feels like more than just a meal; it's an experience that embodies the warmth of the community. Reviewers often mention how quickly they were seated and served, reflecting the cafe’s efficiency even during busy times.
In a town where you can ski in the winter and hike in the summer, Old Tymers Cafe has carved out its niche as a beloved local staple. It draws both locals and travelers who appreciate good food at reasonable prices—where you can relish big portions without breaking the bank.
If you're seeking a cozy spot to enjoy hearty breakfasts, attentive service, and the charm of Red River, Old Tymers Cafe is a destination not to be missed. Come for the pancakes, stay for the welcoming vibe, and leave with a satisfied craving! Don't forget to snap a photo; the memories created here will surely bring you back for more delicious meals.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Food was great until..... we cut into the middle of the pancake. It was nothing but batter. The taste was amazing though. Everything else was great. The servers were very friendly and helpful. I’d definitely return. ”
“ There are two chocolate chip pancakes in this Pic. My bottomless pit 13 yo son couldn't quite finish them. Excellent food, good service. An annual stop for us! ”
“ Went for lunch on a rainy Saturday. My wife ordered the taco salad with beef. The hamburger was a little overcooked, but the rest of the salad was great. I ordered the green chili cheeseburger. Good sized burger green chili had just the right amount of heat. Got tator tots as my side perfectly cooked and a lot of them. Our waitress was great. Kept our drinks filled and was very nice. ”
“ Old Tymers Cafe. Located in a small resort town called Red River. Mostly a ski resort but summers offer bikes, hiking and other stuff. Nice little mile long town. Anyway the food. Main reason I went here... pancakes. They have really big pancakes! You can order 1,2, or 3. Three is a “challenge” if you don’t complete it you have to wash your dishes. If you do, you get a shirt. I actually only had one, thinking they’d be bigger. They were great pancakes. We also had the pork chop with eggs and hash. Also all very good. Thin pork chops, perfectly done eggs and nice crispy hash browns. Service was friendly and fast. We were seated immediately when we got there- but we lucked out on timing, I can see how this place can quickly get a wait, it’s not huge. Great prices. The giant pancake was only 3.50. I wish this place wasn’t a 3 hour drive from home, I’d eat here often! ”
“ Good food, reasonable price, HUGE PANCAKES! Uni-anything bathroom. I love the bottom sign, but then again, I'm easily amused. I posed an updated menu, but it split the two pages apart, so i did it again as a single menu image with a date indicating when it was taken. ”
“ The food was absolutely delicious!!!!! Got the breakfast enchiladas and a pancake! Please eat here such amazing food and people! ”
“ This place is absolutely amazing! The food made my taste buds burst. I’m very satisfied with the service as well. Our server Abby was very nice and positive. I ordered the quesadillas with onion rings. 100 recommend! Thank you ”
“ A must stop! Great breakfast and large portions. Very friendly and accommodating. ”